A blue and black background with a fish

Ordering Food Just Got Easier!

Food & Drink

You Deserve To be Happy!

Come Join Us
Monday - Friday
3-6pm

Happy Hour is Back at
Jerry & The Mermaid!

Food & Drink
Specials At The Bar Only!

Great South Bay Juicy IPA
$5
$5
Great South Bay Twisted Tea
$5
$5
Montauk Watermelon Session Ale
$5
$5
Miller Lite Pints
$5
$5
Trubute Pinot Noir
$8
$8
Chateau St. Jean Merlot
$8
$8
Coastal Estate Chardonnay
$8
$8
San Nicola Pinot Grigio
$8
$8
House Made Sangria
$10
$10
Jerry's "Buffalo" Wings or Tenders
$10
$10
Arugula Salad
$10
$10
Plain Old Mozzarella Sticks
$6
$6
Crispy Edamame Pot Stickers
$6
$6
Clams on 1/2 Shell - Buy 6 Get 6 Free
#BOGO
#BOGO

Lunch & Dinner Menu

THESE ITEM CAN BE PREPARED GLUTEN FREE UPON REQUEST
VEGAN OPTION
*SOME GF MODIFIED ITEMS WILL INCUR A 1.95 SURCHARGE

Hot Appetizers

Crispy Duck 'Wings
$15.95

with asian barbecue drizzle and sesame

$15.95
The Jim Bissett Steamed Dozen
$19.95

hard shelled top neck or little neck clams steamed "luciano style"

$19.95
Baked Stuffed Clams
$14.95

fresh shucked little necks with crispy bacon, onions, mushrooms and garlic compound butter

$14.95
PE1 Mussels Luciano Style
$17.95

white wine and garlic compound butter or marinara sauce

$17.95
Oysters Rockefeller
$16.95

ocal broiled oysters with bacon, caramelized onions and baby spinach

$16.95
Crispy kung Pao Shrimp
$14.95

with thai chili drizzle and shaved baby vegetables 

$14.95
Escargot in Mushroom Caps
$15.95

broiled in garlic, butter, white wine and herbs 

$15.95
Coconut Shrimp
$12.95

with honey aioli 

$12.95
Artichoke Hearts Francaise
$14.95

lightly pan-fried artichokes with white wine and lemon reduction beurre monte

$14.95
Maryland Style Crab Cakes
$16.95

with remoulacle sauce and baby greens

$16.95
Crispy Calamari
$17.95

mild, medium or hot marinara sauce 
ADD:: Banana Peppers 1.95

$17.95
Mozzarella Sticks
$9.50

with marinara sauce 

$9.50
Jerry's 'Famous
Not Your Ordinary "Buffalo"
$9.50

Wings 15.95 Chicken Fingers 15.95 Shrimp 16.95
mild, medium, hot or “make me cry Jerry's sauce”, served with blue cheese and celery
(Traditional “Red Hot” Buffalo Sauce Available Upon Request)

$9.50

Homemade Soup

Manhattan Clam Chowder
$8.50
$8.50
Seafood Bisque
$9.50
$9.50
New England Clam Chowder
$9.50

with hickory smoked bacon 

$9.50

Seafood

SERVED WITH VEGETABLE FRICASSEE AND YOUR
CHOICE OF RICE PILAF OR POTATO DU JOUR

ADD A SIDE SALAD FOR 3.95

Nut Crusted Pangasius
$26.95

mild flavored, white fish with crushed almonds, breadcrumb, compound butter and white wine

$26.95
Cajun Pan Roasted Salmon
$27.95

with wasabi aioli 

$27.95
*Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
$29.95

with soy ginger glaze and wasabi aioli 

$29.95
Broiled Combo
$32.95

bay scallop, pangasius white fish, baked clam and shrimp 

$32.95

Far From The Dock

*Chargrilled NY Strip
$34.95

with Jerry's marinade, gorgonzola crusted and crispy onions 

$34.95
Chicken Francaise
$25.95

lemon and white wine reduction, butter sauce 

$25.95

ABOVE ITEMS SERVED WITH VEGETABLE FRICASSEE AND YOUR CHOICE OF RICE PILAF OR POTATO DU JOUR
ADD A SIDE SALAD FOR 3.95

*Jerry's Marinated Angus
Cheeseburger Platter
$17.50

topped with crispy fried onions, served with waffle fries and cole slaw

$17.50
*Angus Hamburger Platter
$15.50

served with waffle fries and cole slaw 

$15.50

::ADD TO YOUR HAMBURGER::
Cheese, Sauteed Mushrooms or Crispy Fried Onions $1.00 ea • Bacon $1.95
ALL BURGERS ARE SERVED ON A TOASTED BRIOCHE BUN

Crispy Chicken Wings
$17.95

served with waffle fries and cole slaw

$17.95
Crispy Chicken Tenderloins
$14.95

served with waffle fries and Cole slaw

$14.95
The Beyond Burger
$16.95

Plant based vegan product, served on toasted brioche with lettuce, tomato, pickle and waffle fries 

$16.95

WE PROUDLY SERVE COKE PRODUCTS
Coke • Diet Coke • Coke Zero • 7-Up • Ginger Ale Lemonade • Fresh Brewed Ice Tea

PRICES DO NOT INCLUDE SALES TAX

Cold Appetizers

*Sandbar Combo
$19.95

3 Oysters, 3 Clams, 2 Jumbo Shrimp 

$19.95
*Local Clams
(6) $12.95 (12) $19.95

on the half shell (top neck or little neck) 

(6) $12.95 (12) $19.95
*"Wild" Blue Point Oysters
(6) $16.95

on the half shell 

(6) $16.95
*Shrimp Cocktail-tini
(4) $16.95
(4) $16.95

Salads

ADD TO ANY SALAD
GRILLED CHICKEN 5.95 • JUMBO SHRIMP 7.95 SLICED MARINATED SIRLOIN 7.95

Garden Salad
$11.95

mixed greens with seasonal garden vegetables 

$11.95
Baby Arugula Salad
$15.95

baby arugula, dried cranberries, almonds, gorgonzola with balsamic vinaigrette

$15.95
Greek Salad
$14.95
$14.95
Loaded Vegan Salad
$18.95

shredded green leaf, julienne carrots, cabbage, radish, broccoli, cauliflower, quinoa and legume blend 

$18.95

DRESSINGS
House Italian • Balsamic Vinaigrette • Lite Ranch Oil & Vinegar • Bleu Cheese (.75¢ extra)

Mermaids & Pirates

Mermaids & Pirates
$9.95

Hot Dog
Mozzarella Sticks

Breaded Flounder
Crispy Chicken Fingers
Char-Grilled Hamburger
(ADD CHEESE $1.00)
on a toasted brioche bun

Kids Pasta
(RIGATONI OR LINGUINE)
choice of marinara sauce or butter

$9.95

KIDS 12 & UNDER

ALL KIDS ITEMS (EXCEPT PASTA) ARE SERVED WITH CHOICE OF SEASONAL VEGETABLES, SALAD, STRAIGHT CUT FRIES OR WAFFLE FRIES

*PLEASE NOTIFY MANAGEMENT OF ALL ALLERGIES, SO THAT WE CAN BETTER SERVE YOU*

Pasta

GF PASTA CAN BE SUBSTITUTED FOR 1.95
ADD A SIDE SALAD FOR 3.95

Shrimp Scampi
$24.95

over linguine 

$24.95
Rigatoni al la Vodka
$23.95

with cremini mushrooms
ADD :: Chicken 5.95 Shrimp 7.95

$23.95
Linguine with White Clam Sauce
$25.95

local shucked to order clams, white wine, garlic, herbs, evoo and butter

$25.95
Shrimp Parmigiana
$26.95

over linguine 

$26.95
Scungilli Marinara
$29.95

served over linguine available with hot, medium or mild marinara sauce 
ADD ::Sauteed Calamari 5.95

$29.95
Vegan Pasta Primavera
$23.95

with evoo, chopped garlic, assortment of seasonal vegetables and pea shoots

$23.95
Mussels Marinara
$25.95

served over linguine available with hot, medium or mild marinara sauce 

$25.95

*Jerry's Famous Lobster Roll

fresh picked lobster meat, celery, touch of mayo and hint of spice, toasted brioche, green leaf served with waffle fries, cole slaw and pickle
Market Price

*Hot Lobster Roll

fresh picked lobster meat poached in clarified butter, toasted brioche, green leaf, served with waffle fries, cole slaw and pickle
Market Price

Crispy Boats

SERVED WITH WAFFLE FRIES AND COLE SLAW

Fish & Chips
$23.95

beer battered haddock 

$23.95
Mermaid Combo
$23.95

shrimp, clams, scallops and breaded flounder 

$23.95
Jumbo Shrimp
$21.95
$21.95

Sides

Fries
$5.95

(straight or waffle)

$5.95
Sweet Potato Fries
$7.95

with honey aioli 

$7.95
Seasonal Vegetables Fricassee
$8.50
$8.50
Breaded Onion Rings
$7.50
$7.50

BEFORE PLACING YOUR ORDER, PlEASE INFORM YOUR SERVER IF A PERSON IN YOUR PARTY HAS A FOOD ALLERGY.

*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness, especially if you have a medical condition. Management advises that food prepared here may contain or have come in contact with peanuts, tree nuts, soybeans, milk, eggs, wheat, shellfish or fish. Our customer's safety is of our utmost importance. Please do not take any unnecessary risks. Management cannot assure any cross contamination of these ingredients with your dish.

Wraps

Served Monday-Saturday 11 am-3pm
ALL SERVED ON GARLIC HERB WRAP WITH HOUSE SLAW AND PICKLE

Life Guard Chicken Wrap
$14.95

grilled chicken, roasted peppers, mozzarella cheese, lettuce and tomato

$14.95
Crispy Shrimp Wrap
$16.95

with thai chili glaze, shaved vegetables, baby greens and rice

$16.95
Thai Chili Vegan Wrap
$15.95

quinoa blend, thai chili glazed vegetables, shredded green leaf, carrots and radish, on a herb wrap with pickle (no slaw) 

$15.95

Sandwiches

Served Monday-Saturday 11am-3pm
ALL SANDWICHES ARE SERVED WITH WAFFLE FRIES

Blackened Fish Sandwich
$18.95

with house spice blend and remoulade sauce on garlic ciabatta 

$18.95
*Marinated Sliced Sirloin Sandwich
$19.95

with gorgonzola cheese and crispy fried onions 

$19.95
Tuscan Chicken Sandwich
$15.95

with roasted red peppers, mozzarella cheese and balsamic reduction on garlic ciabatta 

$15.95

Desserts

Chocolate 'Peanut /Butter Pie with REESE'S® Peanut Butter Cups

The popular candy bar in a pie. Dark chocolate and peanut butter mousse full of REESE'S® Peanut Butter Cups.
The REESE'S® trademark is used under license.

Baked Apple Tart

Warm baked apple tart with homemade caramel sauce.
*THIS IS BAKED T0 ORDER AND NEEDS A FEW EXTRA MINUTES TO REACH PERFECTION - PLEASE PRE-ORDER!*

Jerry's 'Homemade Ice Cream-Stuffed Crepe

Jerry's signature ice cream stuffed crepe with homemade hot fudge and whipped cream.

Creme Brulee D'jour

Jerry's homemade crème brulee! Ask your server for today's seasonal flavor.

Molten, Chocolate Cake

Five layers of dark, moist chocolate cake sandwiched with the silkiest smooth chocolate filling and finished with elegant dark chocolate ganache.

Creme Brulee Cheesecake

The marriage of two great classics.. creme brulee layered and a-mingle with the lightest of cheesecakes to create something unimaginably luscious. Hand-fired and mirrored with burnt caramel.

Brownie Sundae

The star of these irresistible gluten-free brownies is the purely dark Honduran chocolate mixed into every batch. Topped with vanilla bean ice cream and homemade hot fudge.

Four High Carrot Cake

Layer upon layers of moist carrot cake, stuffed with raisins, walnuts and pineapple. Finished with smooth cream cheese icing and a drizzle of white chocolate ganache.

Cocktail List

Tito's Lavender Mule

Tito's Handmade Vodka,
Homemade Lavender Simple Syrup,
Ginger Beer & Fresh Lime

Peconic Rum Punch

Bellamy Spiced Rum, Silver Rum,
Mixed with The House Secret Recipe of Pineapple, Orange & Lime Juice

Jerry's Signature Bloody Mary

Skyy Vodka, Jerry's Signature Bloody Mary Mix & a Shrimp Cocktail

1800 Coconut Margarita

1800 Coconut, Pineapple, Sour, Lime & Toasted Coconut Flakes

Homemade Rose Sangria

Granny Smith Apple, Cara Cara Orange, Fortified Spirits & Simple Syrup

Pear Vodka Breeze

Absolute Pear, Pineapple, Cranberry & Fresh Lime

The Whale Flower

Gray Whale Gin, Elderflower Liqueur, Grapefruit Juice, Soda Water & Sprig Lavender

Stoli "OO" Cosmo

Stoli Orange Vodka, Triple Sec, Lime, Splash Orange & Cranberry

Aperol Spritz

Prosecco, Aperol & Soda Water

Redemption "Rye Tai"

Redemption Rye, Orgeat/Almond Syrup, Pineapple, Lemon Juice, Bitters

Astral Sunrise

Astral Blanco Tequila, Orange Juice & Pomegranate Syrup

Canned Cocktails

Fisher's Island Lemonade 9%
Montauk Distilling Co. "Mermaid Water" Hard Seltzer
(Blackberry or Mango)

Draft beer

  • Great South Bay Blonde Ambition
  • Blue Point Toasted
  • Blue Point Seasonal
  • Montauk Wavechaser IPA
  • Coney Island Mermad IPA
  • Shelter Island Pilsner
  • Miller Lite

Bottle / Can Beer

  • Heineken
  • Heineken 00
    (Non Alcoholic)
  • Strongbow Cider
  • Bud/BudLight
  • Corona
  • Michelob Ultra
  • Omission Lager (Gluten Free)
  • Montauk Seasonal Can
  • Guinness (Pub Can)
  • North Shore Irish Red (Mattituck)

White Wine

"Chef Lorenzo's" Casa Segreta
Orvieto Classico
Beddell (NoFo, LI) Viognier
San Nicola, Pinot Grigio (Italy)
BV Coastal, Chardonnay (California)
Ca Del Doge, Prosecco (Italy)
Margaret, Sauvignon Blanc (South Africa)
Pugliese Vineyards (NoFo LI), Riesling
Cupcake Vineyards, Moscato (Venezie)
Martha Clara (NoFo LI), Chardonnay

Rose Wine

Montauk Daisy, Rosé (NoFo LI)

Red Wine

Silver Peak, Cabernet Sauvignon (CA)
Chateau St Jean, Merlot (California)
Tribute, Pinot Noir (California)

Dessert Menu

Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie with REESE'S® Peanut Bunn Cups

The popular candy bar in a pie. Dark chocolate and peanut butter mousse full of REESE'S® Peanut Butter Cups.
The REESE'S® trademark is used under license.

Baked Apple Tart

Warm baked apple tart with homemade caramel sauce.
*This is baked to order and needs a few extra minutes to reach perfection - please pre-order!*

Jerry's Homemade Ice Cream-Stuffed Crepe

Jerry's signature ice cream stuffed crepe with homemade hot fudge and whipped cream.

Creme Brulee D'Jour

Jerry's homemade crème brulee!
Ask your server for today's seasonal flavor.

Molten Chocolate Cake

Five layers of dark, moist - chocolate cake sandwiched with the silkiest smooth chocolate filling and finished with elegant dark chocolate ganache.

Creme Brulee Cheesecake

The marriage of two great classics ... crème brulee layered and a-mingle with the lightest of cheesecakes to create something unimaginably luscious. Hand-fired and mirrored with burnt caramel.

Gluten Free Brownie Sundae

Baked with only cage-free eggs, our blend of gluten-free flour, sustainable chocolates and ingredients free of gmo's, artificial additives and nuts, the star of these irresistible brownies is the purely dark Honduran chocolate mixed into every batch. Topped with vanilla bean ice cream and homemade hot fudge.

Specialty Cocktails

Jerry's Cappuccino

with vanilla ice cream, Anisette & Galliano liquor

Espresso Martini

With Stoli® Vanilla Vodka, Kahlua®, Baileys® Irish Cream & espresso

Oatmeal Cookie Martini

Butterscotch Schnapps, Baileys Irish Cream, Amaretto & Cinnamon

Biscotini

Stoli® Vanilla Vodka, Frangelico®, Amaretto & Malibu® Coconut Rum

Chocolate Martini

Stoli Vanilla Vodka, Creme de Coco & Godiva® Chocolate Liquor

International Coffees

Irish • French • Italian • Mexican

*Ask Your Server About Our Extensive Selection of Liquors & After Dinner Drinks!

Beverages

Coffee • Tea • Cappuccino • Espresso

*All Available Regular or Decaf*

A green and blue background with a wave